OutlineIn everyday parlance, charisma is often used as a colorful
synonym for sex appeal or popularity. It is also invoked to
explain how certain types of people become leaders. Yet,
the reverse is more likely to be true: very few national
political leaders selected by established party and electoral
processes are charismatic. Charisma comes from the
Greek kahrisma: gift of grace, the partaking of the
divine. Weber emphasizes that charisma refers to "an
extraordinary quality of a person, ... to which the governed
submit because of their belief " (Gerth and Mills
1946, 52 and 295.)
The vertical axis places charisma between the group
which acknowledges the sign of grace and the leadership
role to which the chosen or self-selected person is anointed.
The horizontal axis traces the development from the
originating crisis - the "charismatic moment" - toward
its likely output: institutionalization.
The lower left quadrant (LLQ) covers the moment
thought by followers to be the extraordinary birth. The
primordial charismatic character often has a religious
origin and is recognized according to how he or she
appears to possess supernatural qualities and style befitting
"an envoy of God, a hero - a mighty warrior" (Boudon and Borricaud 1989, 69). The upper left
quadrant (ULQ) depicts charisma in movement, arising
out of crises that so often beset communities. Crisis produces
a quest for a return to the foundations of the community.
And when action and conflict are required, people
become followers, having put their trust in a figure
known for effectiveness, heroism, sacrifice, prophecy, or
prayer.
In the upper right quadrant (URQ), the community
is on a more rational footing, emerging as an institution
whose need for leadership must be more in keeping with
established rules and practices that actually define an
institution and are in the process rationalized by supporting
beliefs - i.e., the function of ideology. It is this
quadrant that best applies to one of Weber's most luminous
discoveries, the "routinization of charisma." The
lower right quadrant (LRQ) is a still more formalized
version of routinization, in which rationalization is
crafted directly in terms of a monocratic authority.
Charisma is here instrumental to the founding of a new
political order, be it the early monarchies of the thaumaturgic
kings healing their followers or the authoritarian
regimes of revolutionary leaders.
|